From Feros Group comes Huxley’s and Ugly Pizza – A pair of connected venues with Huxley’s sports bar hidden behind what looks like the freezer doors inside Ugly Pizza. The venues however are anything but ugly with smart fitouts by Chris Ginham (who designed both Chiswick and Opera Bar). Ugly Pizza has a functional minimalist, warm and intimate space that’s visible from the streetside – And operations at Ugly’s have been a smashing success since opening and they’ve had to take their oversized pizzas off the menu as demand overwhelmed the pizza ovens here. Crossing the gateway into Huxley’s and you’ll enter a slick NYC sports bar with rather contrasting characteristic. And yes the gateway is a fridge door, a bit of a concealed surprise and a bit fancier than the suburb of Caringbah would have suggested. Straight out of the surryhills and sydney CBD rulebooks then.

Huxley Ugly Pizza Caringbah (11)

Huxley Ugly Pizza Caringbah (2)

Huxley Ugly Pizza Caringbah (1)

Huxley Ugly Pizza Caringbah (3)

That unlikely concealed entrace to Huxley’s right there behind the fridge doors

Huxley Ugly Pizza Caringbah (5)

Huxley Ugly Pizza Caringbah (7)

Huxley Ugly Pizza Caringbah (6)

Inside, a stark contrast as Huxley’s dimly lit and there is an array of large screen tv showing sportscast around the venue. The feel is less neighbourhood pub and much slicker, that high end NYC sports bar lineage. Neon signage adds hints of colour to the space and there’s ample artwork to add points of visual interest. The venue has a range of deep plush settes and booths and on this Wednesday night visit, filling up with a demographic of early 20s to 40s. One party celebrated their birthday here. The mood is congenial and easy.

From Ugly Pizza, you’ll get a range of Pizzas and burgers but inside Huxley’s the food menu expands (you can also get the Ugly Pizza Menu in here) but extends to a larger Americana menu of hotdogs, wings, ribs, burgers, pizzas, beers and more. It should be noted that both Huxley’s and Ugly Pizza has a Feros Group members price where dishes are ($1-2 cheaper; refer menu)

Huxley Ugly Pizza Caringbah (9)
Huxley Ugly Pizza Caringbah (10)
Navigating Huxley’s you’ll possibly spot their eye-catching tall beer towers; a 2 litre table side serve of your bevvie of choice. We went with an American Sierra Nevada Pale. A floral hoppy, deep amber, full bodied american beer.

Huxley Ugly Pizza Caringbah (8)

The Ugly Pizza Menu. Yes, there’s burgers, pizzas, salads and Garlic Breads and dessert options.

Huxley Ugly Pizza Caringbah (13)

Buffalo Wings $16 Franks Hot Sauce, Blue Cheese Mayo, Celery Crudités

Huxley Ugly Pizza Caringbah (17)

Bbq Pork Riblettes $21 House Smoked Pork Riblettes, Sticky Cola Sauce

Huxley Ugly Pizza Caringbah (15)

Loaded Waffle Fries $15 Bacon, Nacho Cheese, Sour Cream, Shallots

Huxley Ugly Pizza Caringbah (14)

Pulled Beef Nachos – Nacho Cheese, Sour Cream, Guacamole, Pico De Gallo, House Fried Corn Chips

The selection of eats from the starter side of Huxley’s menu are generous sized bites. Hot wings are tangy from the vinegary Frank’s hot sauce. A fiesty set of wing done right. Guacamole and chips and loaded waffle fries both abundant and packed full of flavour; its the sort of sides you’ll dig into quite happily. We loved these and the House Fried Corn Chips are a nice touch. Huxley’s BBQ Pork rilettes are juicy flavoursome mini bites.

Huxley Ugly Pizza Caringbah (19)

Foot Long Double Dogs: Coney Island $21 Skinless Beef Franks, Pulled Chilli Beef, Minced Onion, American Mustard

On the menu, a ridiculously oversized double dog, best shared of course. With a tasty beef frank in it and most importantly good bread, made for a good hotdog. Good for a big eater; best shared.

Huxley Ugly Pizza Caringbah (18)

Huxley Burger – Signature Beef Blend, Cheddar, Pickle, Lettuce, Tomato, Huxley’s Burger Sauce

Huxley’s signature burger was pretty great. A juicy, beef number with salad and a nice soft bun. It’s simplicity belies how good it was. They do these on Thursdays for $10 (best to check the website)

Huxley Ugly Pizza Caringbah (12)

Huxley’s and Ugly Pizza both have a level of finesse that belies its location in Caringbah. If this was more local to where we were, we’d be regulars and that’s about as good a recommendation we can give this. Delicious eats and a perfect NYC sports bar experience complemented with beers and atmosphere. Get in here during game days, we hear it gets pretty kick ass.

Huxley’s Bar and Ugly Pizza

Huxley’s

32 Banksia Road, Caringbah, Sydney, NSW

Huxley's Menu, Reviews, Photos, Location and Info - Zomato